Zim remains trapped in debt distress

Author Name
Respect Gwenzi
Analysis 10 months ago

Zimbabwe is in debt distress and this could provide the biggest challenge on efforts to recover the economy from the abyss of collapse. Finance and Economic Development Minister Professor Mthuli Ncube presented a ZWL$421.6 billion 2021 National Budget on Thursday, and once again it leaves more questions than answers.

According to the budget statement, the country’s external debt is estimated at US$8.2 billion, as at end September 2020 which is an increase by US$106 million from the end 2019 amount of US$8.09 billion and was mainly on account of penalties and interest arrears.

“Of the total external debt, 17% is owed by public entities through guarantees,” Minister Ncube said.

Government through its National Development Strategy 1 (NDS1) launched last week said worsening the country’s debt position was the rapid accumulation of external arrears.

“There is high risk of moral hazard, with many public entities approaching government for debt assumption,” the NDS1 says.

According to the budget statement, total Public and Publicly Guaranteed (PPG) debt is estimated at 78.7% of GDP by end of 2020 and the debt stock is marginally above the SADC recommended threshold of 60% of GDP and the Public Debt Act threshold of 70% of GDP.

Minister Ncube further highlighted that domestic debt as at 30 September 2020 was ZWL$12.5 billion, which is 1.2% of GDP and 1.8% of the total public debt.

While domestic debt has been stable, and seemingly more sustainable to service, external debt is highly unsustainable given the current shortages in forex to service the obligations. Two-thirds of this debt are arrears and with the economy coming from a two-year dip, it is unlikely to see any repayment in 2021.

The domestic economy, which, in 2018-20 was confronted with climatic, macroeconomic and the current Covid-19 shocks, is projected to contract by – 4.5% in 2020 as per the Ministers projections. However, other independent projections like Equity Axis foresee a worse downturn at about -10% in 2020.

For any future financing from IFIs, requires the authorities to clear the arrears first which is unlikely in the near time. It is worthy to note that, Zimbabwe’s debt management legal framework is rated quite strongly by development partners such as the World Bank and the Macroeconomic and Financial Management Institute as one that meets minimum standards for debt management. But, the government has been failing to comply with the law.

The ballooning external debt could prove the major setback in the government’s efforts to revive the ailing economy. While stability has been noticed over the recent months on exchange rate and inflation trends, there are high fears that the stability is highly unsustainable.

If the Zimbabwe dollar further depreciates value, and budget deficit persists in addition to the rapid accumulation of external arrears, toxic as that combination is, the country will by no means manage to safely carry the debt.

Stock Market ● 1 week ago
Room for FMCG ETF on ZSE

Since its January 4th debut on the ZSE this year, Old Mutual Limited's Exchange Traded Fund (ETF) has had an impressive run so far, presenting a good case for market interest in alternative financial investment instruments through formal & regulated channels. YTD price up 300% YTD market cap up 616% at ZWL 574.5m Broadly speaking, the ETF tracks and mirrors trading performance of the ZSE’s...

Stock Market ● 3 weeks ago
Cassava's trade suspension another thorn in ETF's side

Having violated ZSE listing requirements, shares of Cassava Smartech have been suspended from trading (effective October 1st 2021). The firm was due to publish its set of financial statements for the year-ended February 2021. Seven months later & no financials are out. Cassava’s market cap stood at ZWL 81.5 billion, with the firm well-positioned among the ZSE’s basket of “market heavies” – the To...

Stock Market ● 3 weeks ago
ZSE sustains record highs as magnitude subsides

The ZSE sustained record-breaking momentum in mid-week trades albeit at subsiding levels. The mainstream All Share Index surged by 1.97% in today’s session, a slow-down from an average daily gain of 3.7% over the past 5 days, to close at an all-time high of 8586.7 points. This is due to a -78% decline in demand as well as subsiding margins in market heavies and penny stocks respectively. On t...

Markets ● 3 weeks ago
Suppressed HY-21, Rosy Year-End Lined-Up For RTG

In the six-months ended June 2021, the Rainbow Tourism Group's occupancy closed the period at 24%, a 4% improvement from prior year levels. Inflation-adjusted revenue grew to ZWL 706m from ZWL 462m, representing a 53% growth. The Group says that in the face of business interruptions, gross margins managed to rise from 63% to 67% in the period. At ZWL 161m, EBITDA ended the half-year 6% down from...

Stock Market ● 3 weeks ago
Challenging the ZSE's "top performing stock market" narrative

After surpassing its own performance record (again), the ZWL-denominated exchange extended 2021 gains as the market’s counters continue facing economic uncertainties in the closing quarter of the year. Index up 198% YTD ZWL continues to depreciate Parallel market remains out of control Unlike steady-moving regional peers, the ZSE’s All Share Index (ASI) has nearly doubled its 2020 year-end...